Pretty much. I can give you hours of argument as to why she was, objectively, the WORST of the four (alright, five) captains. From the unconscionable decision to violate the Prime Directive and strand her crew in a hostile and unknown part of the galaxy to her racism to her hypocrisy, she’s just the worst.
That Trekkers (and worse, gay Trekkers) pledge blind allegiance to her JUST because she’s a woman makes it all worse. Now, I’ll allow for the view that Voyager as an entire show was mismanaged, poorly written and overly reliant on gimmicks. But that’s the greatest crime of it all - Star Trek: Voyager started out with real potential to explore the lengths to which people stick to their principals.
Voyager the ship was gorgeous, the crew was interesting and the premise really cool. It’s too bad the whole thing turned into a giant mess, largely because of Janeway’s exceedingly poor leadership.